• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Phone: 3465 9332

Logo
  • Home
  • Our Team
    • Courtney Barton – Legal Practice Director & Founder
    • George Finn – Executive Director
    • Ellie Prior – Solicitor
    • Tenayah Miano – Paralegal
  • Our Services
    • Divorce Property Settlement Lawyers
    • Family Law Spousal Maintenance
    • Superannuation Splitting & Advice Lawyers
    • Child Custody Lawyers
    • Child Support Lawyers
    • Child Relocation Family Lawyers
    • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
    • Fixed Fee Consent Orders Brisbane
    • Binding Financial Agreements
    • Fixed Fee Divorce Lawyers
    • Domestic Violence Lawyer – DVO Domestic Violence Order
    • Child Adoption Lawyer & Advice
    • Family Court Process
    • Family Mediation Services Brisbane
      • Why Mediate with the Brisbane Family mediator?
      • Contact the Brisbane Family Mediator
      • Barton Family Mediation Costs & Processes
        • Barton Family Mediation Fixed Fees
  • Fixed Fees
  • Common questions
  • Family Law Videos
  • Family Mediation
  • Contact Us
  • Success Stories

Application to change parenting orders because of children’s changed views dismissed

May 1, 2020 By Barton Family Law

An Application to change a parenting order is an uphill battle, which will not lightly be entertained by a Court as to do so would invite endless litigation.

When will a court change a parenting order?

For a court to reverse an earlier parenting order, it must be satisfied that there has been a significant change in circumstances since the order was made or a new factor arising which was not disclosed at the previous hearing, which would have been material to the Judge’s decision.

This principle was determined in the case of Rice & Asplund.

Even if there has been a significant change in circumstances, a change to the orders must be considered by the Court to be in the children’s best interests.

In Marsden & Winch [2009] FamCAFC 152, the Full Court set out a 2 step process for determining whether a parenting application should be reopened:

  1. That a prima facie case of changed circumstances has been established;
  2. That there is a sufficient change in circumstances so as to justify embarking on a hearing.

What are some examples of significant changes in circumstances?

There is no defined list as to what constitutes a significant change in circumstances as each case is determined on its own merits.

However, some changed circumstances which may be considered significant by a court, so as to justify changing a parenting order, are:

  • A parent who is addicted to drugs getting clean;
  • a parent who is an alcoholic, being sober;
  • A parent becoming addicted to drugs/alcohol where they were not  before;
  • A parent developing a mental health issue which affects their capacity as a parent;
  • A parent obtaining treatment for their mental health such that their capacity as a parent has improved;
  • A parent moving further away from the children such that the current parenting orders are now frustrated;
  • A parent moving significantly closer to the children such that the current parenting orders are not appropriate and in the children’s best interests;
  • A parent sexually abusing a child;
  • A child developing a mental health issue;
  • A parent going to jail for a serious charge such that they are no
  • A parent not spending time with the children in accordance with a court order for a significant period, but then attempts to enforce compliance with that order;
  • A parent threatening to harm the children and/or the other parent (usually in conjunction with drug use, anger management and/or mental health issues coming to light);
  • A parent’s living circumstances changing in a dramatic way.
  • A child being older than when the orders were originally made is expressing very strong views.

The Judge has discretion as to whether to consider the ‘Rice & Asplund’ principle as a preliminary issue (at the first court date) or after a full contested hearing.

Where possible, the Judge will deal with it as a preliminary issue so as to minimise the legal costs of the parties and the impact on the children if the court proceedings were reopened.

Importantly, for the court to assess that any of the above factors constitutes a significant change in circumstances, so as to justify reopening a parenting order, the changed circumstances need to be supported by evidence. 

The burden of establishing a prima facie case of changed circumstances at a preliminary hearing so as to justify embarking on a new Hearing lies with the applicant seeking to change the parenting order.

If there is no evidence other than the sworn evidence of the parent about that changed circumstance, the Court may dismiss your application, with costs.

Findlay & Reis [2020] FCCA 425

In Findlay & Reis, Judge Hughes dismissed an interim application by the father to vary parenting orders which had been in force for six (6) years, by which the children (now 13 and 11) were spending four nights per fortnight with him. His application sought equal time.

The mother’s application for dismissal was listed as a preliminary hearing.

The father’s case was that the children had repeatedly asked to spend week about time with him, that they were sufficiently mature to have not weight given to their views and that he was in a stable new relationship. Note: his case was based predominantly on the children’s age and their views allegedly expressed directly to him about wanting to spend more time with him.

After citing Rice & Asplund and the test in Marsden & Winch, the Court stated:

“the mother said the only occasion on which [equal time] was raised with her was..the result of the father’s influence and a desire by the children to meet his need to have an arrangement which is ‘fair’ as between the parents. The veracity of the competing evidence about the children’s views is not something I am able to determine on the strength of the untested affidavit material..

Based on the limited untested evidence before me, I am not persuaded further litigation will likely result in a substantial change in the children’s arrangements given the high level of acrimony and resentment between the three significant adults..The potential benefit to be derived by the children from any change is in my view, outweighed by the negative aspects the children will be required to endure for a period of more than 12 months until a trial can occur.” 

Importantly, there was no independent evidence put by the Father of the changed circumstances and the court focused on the benefit versus the detriment for the children of the application being allowed to proceed to hearing.

What should I do if I want to change a parenting order?

If you are seeking a change to a parenting order, you will need to first attempt to negotiate those changes with your former partner.

By negotiating an agreement out of court, you will be able to avoid costly and lengthy litigation.

If an agreement is able to be reached, that agreement can be formalised by a consent order, filed with the family court of Australia.

If an agreement to change a parenting order is not forthcoming, you will need to file an application to the federal circuit court seeking a change to the parenting orders, and you will need to satisfy the court that there has been a significant change in circumstances since the parenting order was made.

At Barton Family Lawyers, we assist our client’s to negotiate and formalise final parenting agreements, through alternative dispute resolution and we recommend court action only as a last resort.

Wondering whether you have a case for a change to your final parenting orders?

Contact our Petrie family law experts to book a reduced rate consultation today for advice in relation to your specific circumstances.

For more information on when a parenting order can be changed. Click the below picture for an explanation by Courtney.

reduced rate initial consultation

Filed Under: News

Barton Family Law

Primary Sidebar

Online Enquiry

I would like to book a reduced rate initial consultation with you

Footer

Areas of Practice

  • Child Custody Lawyers
  • Divorce Property Settlement Lawyers
  • Fixed Fee Divorce Lawyers
  • Domestic Violence Lawyer – DVO Domestic Violence Order
  • Superannuation Splitting & Advice Lawyers
  • Fixed Fee Consent Orders Brisbane
  • Mediation Representation
  • Child Relocation Family Lawyers
  • Child Abduction Family Lawyers
  • Child Support Lawyers
  • Family Law Spousal Maintenance
  • Child Adoption Lawyer & Advice
  • Family Court Process
  • Family Mediation Services Brisbane
  • Binding Financial Agreements

Common Questions & Concerns

  • How to spend more time with your children
  • What is substantial and significant time 
  • Parental Alienation in Family Court Disputes – Pt 1
  • Parental Alienation in Family Court Disputes – Pt 2 
  • Top 10 things people do wrong in child custody matters
  • What age can a child decide where they live?
  • Admissibility of recordings in family law cases 
  • Am I a parent?
  • I’m Not a parent. Can I apply for a parenting order? 
  • I want sole custody
  • Can I go to court without doing mediation first?
  • Can parenting orders be changed? 
  • Relocation of Children
  • Interim relocation of children cases
  • Unilateral relocation of children
  • International travel with children after separation
  • My ex is breaching a parenting order. What do I do? 
  • When is supervised time ordered?
  • Is a child’s changed views enough to change a parenting order? 
  • Interim parenting orders – why can’t the judge make the orders I want? 
  • When can you change your child’s surname?
  • What is substantial & significant time?
  • Domestic violence order applications – boosting prospects of success
  • What to do and what not to do when you separate
  • Why you should formalise your property settlement;
  • Is Domestic violence relevant in a property settlement?
  • 6 secrets revealed to protect your assets 
  • 10 tips to protect your assets
  • 6 things you must know before hiring a family lawyer
  • Your Duty of Disclosure 
  • Spousal Maintenance – supporting your ex partner after separation 
  • Initial contribution of assets in a long relationship 
  • What is the just and equitable requirement?
  • Chancellor & Mccoy – no order after 27 yr relationship
  • Am I in a de facto relationship?
  • My ex is selling assets. What can I do?
  • Property acquired after separation – how is it treated? 
  • When are future inheritances they taken into account?
  • Failure to disclose an asset can derail consent orders 
  • Consequences of Defaulting on property orders 
  • Varying property orders 
  • Who stays in the home after separation?
  • Can the court order someone to leave the house – ouster orders 
  • Money lent from parents – gift or loan?
  • The impact of centrelink fraud on a property settlement 
  • CGT rollover relief for transfers of property pursuant to family court orders 
  • Costs orders 
  • Divorce – what you need to know
  • Going back to work after divorce 
  • Step-Parent awarded interim custody over parent 

If you are a law student, graduate or early career lawyer, reach out to Courtney who is also a law Coach. Courtney’s law coaching services are invaluable to young lawyers. Courtney’s one on one law coaching services will help you to achieve massive success in your legal career.  Check out Courtney’s website for the Thriving Young Lawyer to learn more about Courtney’s law coaching services.

Individual liability limited by a scheme approved under professional standards legislation.

Contact Us

Head office

  • Address: 4/996 Anzac Avenue, Petrie QLD 4501
  • Parking: Underground parking available at the back of the building via O’Loan Street
  • Phone: 3465 9332
  • Email: george.finn@bartonfamilylaw.com.au
  • Website: Petrie Family Lawyers

Northside – Chermside Office

  • Address: 822 Gympie Road, Chermside QLD 4032
  • Phone: 3465 9332
  • Email: george.finn@bartonfamilylaw.com.au
  • Website: Chermside Family Lawyers

Aspley Office

  • Address: Aspley Hypermarket, 59 Albany Creek Road, Aspley QLD 4034
  • Phone: 3465 9332
  • Email: tenayah.miano@bartonfamilylaw.com.au
  • Website: Aspley Family Lawyers

Toowong Office

  • Address: Toowong Tower Level 5, Toowong Tower, 9 Sherwood Road, Toowong, QLD 4066
  • Phone: 3465 9332
  • Email: tenayah.miano@bartonfamilylaw.com.au
  • Website: Toowong Family Lawyers

Copyright © 2020 · Privacy Policy
Created and hosted by LEAP · Log in